Chief constable recruitment brought forward following legal challenge threat

Monday, 16 November 2026 at 14:02

By Alison Stephenson, Local Democracy Reporter

The recruitment of a substantive chief constable of Devon and Cornwall Police has been brought forward following the threat of a legal challenge.

The process, planned for 2028, will begin later this month
Police and crime commissioner Alison Hernandez has received a letter from the Chief Police Officers’ Staff Association (CPOSA) outlining their intention to pursue a legal action regarding her decision to extend the contract of the interim chief constable James Vaughan without running a recruitment process. 
The commissioner said: “I acknowledge this is a legitimate challenge to a decision that was made in good faith and both Mr Vaughan and I are eager to avoid spending public funds on a lengthy legal battle.”    
“As a result of this challenge, and by mutual consent with Mr Vaughan, a full chief constable recruitment process will begin when an advert inviting applications for the role goes live in week commencing November 30.” 
Mr Vaughan will continue serving as the interim chief constable pending the outcome of this process which is likely to conclude early in 2027.  
In September this year, the commissioner announced her decision to extend Mr Vaughan’s contract to August 2028 to secure stable leadership.    
She added: “The recruitment of a substantive chief constable comes at a challenging time for the force, and will inevitably be a distraction, but my office will now conduct an open process supported by the College of Policing.” 
The force was recently downgraded from level two to level three by His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS) because its performance had deteriorated in supervising investigations to safeguard victims, previously highlighted as a cause for concern in the 2025-27 PEEL inspection. 
HMICFRS also issued an accelerated cause of concern to the force because the force’s strategic leaders were” failing to provide effective leadership”. 
An accelerated cause of concern is a measure reserved for situations involving significant service failures or risks to public safety. 
Mr Vaughan was appointed as interim chief constable in December 2024 following the suspension of the then acting chief constable Jim Colwell who was later cleared of gross misconduct allegations, and his contract extended by the commissioner on two occasions.
The officer oversaw the force’s move out of special measures after three years in July 2025 and spearheaded Operation Resolve to move 200 officers back to the frontline.
Ms Hernandez extended Mr Vaughan’s contract to 2028 in September so he would remain in post beyond the government’s plans to abolish the police and crime commissioner’s role in May 2028.
She said at the time he had provided “strong and effective” leadership during a period of significant change for Devon and Cornwall Police.
“Under his leadership, we have seen important cultural improvements within the organisation that are now translating into tangible improvements in performance and service delivery for our communities.”
 

More from Local News

On Air Now Non Stop Evenings 6:00pm - Midnight
Now Playing
I Can Make You Feel Good Shalamar Download
Recently Played

Schedule

Today's Weather

  • Exmouth

    Heavy rain shower

    High: 10°C | Low: 9°C

  • Exeter

    Heavy rain shower

    High: 9°C | Low: 8°C

  • Dawlish

    Heavy rain shower

    High: 11°C | Low: 10°C

  • Torquay

    Heavy rain shower

    High: 11°C | Low: 10°C

  • Sidmouth

    Heavy rain shower

    High: 10°C | Low: 9°C

Easy Fundraising

What's On